A United Nations human rights expert says Israel has ignored proportionality in an "unrelenting bombardment of Gaza" that's seen more than 11,000 Palestinians killed.
Subscribe now for unlimited access.
or signup to continue reading
UN special rapporteur for the occupied Palestinian territory Francesca Albanese used a National Press Club address to declare Israel's right to self-defence is "non-existent".
Ms Albanese claimed international law doesn't let a country invoke self-defence when the threat comes from a country it occupies.
"Israel cannot claim the right of self-defence against a threat that emanates from the territory ... that is kept under belligerent occupation," she said.
"Israel was allowed to act to establish law and order to repel the attack, neutralise whoever was carrying out the attacks and then proceed with law and order measures ... not waging a war."
She called for a ceasefire in the Middle East and for all Israeli hostages held by Hamas after the October 7 attacks to be released, along with an arms embargo and humanitarian corridors to be created.
But Ms Albanese insisted a plan to end the occupation of Palestine was just as important, believing that would ensure another form of resistance doesn't emerge even if Hamas is eliminated.
She took aim at the targeting of a Palestinian refugee camp and labelled it a war crime, arguing that even if it eliminated a Hamas operative, proportionality could not be ensured.
"Let's assume there was one Hamas operative Israel wanted to target and kill - in order to kill that person, the lives of hundreds of Palestinians ... have been endangered," she said.
"This is clearly not respecting the principle of distinction, for which a military action needs to be proportionate to the military goal and principle of proportion."
Ms Albanese, who has repeatedly condemned Hamas' attacks, argued ending the "Jewish-Israeli dominance" in Palestine would be a "real humanising act".
More than 100 UN staff have been killed in Gaza since October 7, which makes it the most lethal conflict in the organisation's history.
The Executive Council of Australian Jewry claimed the comments denied Israel's right to defend itself, despite Ms Albanese stating: "Israel clearly ... has the sacrosanct right and duty to protect itself, its territory, its citizens."
She said Israel was being threatened by Hamas - "an armed group" - and not a state, adding under international law it did not have the right to "wage war".
ECAJ co-CEO Peter Wertheim said the distinction between the threat coming from a state or a terrorist organisation was not made out.
"Both the UN charter and customary international law clearly affirm the inherent right of a state to use force in response to an armed attack," he said in a statement.
Australian Associated Press
